I wasn't sure whether or not to keep it in color or B&W so I posted both!! Here is the B&W

www.vazaar.com/topic:black-white-photos/photos/id:...

I wasn't sure about keeping the first black key in the photo. Let me know what you think!!!

I like it in color!

I like the use of the keys as a lead in line. Great composition

Can't decide about color vs. b&w, like them both. I might have been nice to see 2 black at the start, but not bad the way it is. I love the reflections along the left edge. They are what make me not decide about the color thing. In b&w I like the overall tonal range and feel better, but in the color those reflections are super nice.

Good idea, especially the composition and shallow DOF. It's hard to choose between color and b&w, but I think I like the b&w more. I love the reflections of the black keys!

Only minus imo: the reflection on the wooden board. I don't know for sure, but maybe a polarisation filter can prevent that (I'm experimenting with different kinds of filters myself at the moment).

Great picture. I like the B&W, but i think i like the colour better.

This is a wonderful image. In my opinion would be even better if 2 cm from the top is cropped out.

For me the color wins hands down - very beautiful work on this photo.

Cheers,
Jon

i also like the color one better but the white balance seems to be slightly off (too much blue)
i like the reflection in the keys
i also agree that you should try to crop out the top