You are not logged in | Login

User koo88 / Critiques / Photo #21480

Uploaded by koo88 - 11 comments - Topic: Silhouettes (11 months ago)  


Copyright © koo88
Unauthorized reproduction not permitted.

In Topic

Silhouettes (11 months ago)  

User Comments

sesameseeds added a critique 11 months ago:

I am new at this...but to me this is so beautiful and natural...straight from the camera! Good eye!

koo88 said 11 months ago:

Thank you very much. Some tweaking with PS

Beamer (Clyde Beamer) added a critique 11 months ago:

It does look a bit over processed. Is this a crop out of a larger image, sorta looks like it. I do think you let the sky get a bit too noisy.

koo88 said 11 months ago:

I always appreciate the criticism that I recieve. It makes me work harder to improve. I only cropped it a little. There was another tree that I took out. Can you explain what too noisy means?

Beamer (Clyde Beamer) added a critique 11 months ago:

Noisy means something like grain, but not as natural looking. This can be made worse by heavy post processing.

This might help:

www.photoxels.com/tutorial_noise.html

koo88 said 11 months ago:

Beamer thanks for the definition. I see what you mean. Maybe I will post the photo before I used PS. I have the mentality that photos are meant to be what is captured, and not tampered with. I understand that it is the age of digital photography and must go with the flow of the times. Just my own personal critique. What do you think?

lightholder (Kimberly Lightholder) added a critique 11 months ago:

It's a beautiful photo, but it does appear to suffer from low resolution. Was it taken on a compact?

koo88 said 11 months ago:

It was taken on a cannon powershot sd750 point and shoot. I just got photo shop and was playing around.

turkana (César) added a critique 11 months ago:

The colors of the sky are incredibles!!!

jvgphoto (jon van gilder) added a critique 8 months ago:

With some judicious cropping this could still be a powerful shot - even with all the noise pollution.

Best,
Jon

narnold (Noah Arnold) added a critique 8 months ago:

I can't really add on to what has already been said...the colors are beautiful!

You could comment on this photo if you were logged in.