You are not logged in | Login

User Ana / Critiques / Photo #26006

Uploaded by Ana - 6 comments - Topic: Gardens (10 months ago)  


Copyright © Ana (Ana Cortez) - imageanalogy.my-expressions.com/
Unauthorized reproduction not permitted.

In Topic

Gardens (10 months ago)  

User Comments

AnaGaztelu (Ana Gaztelu) added a critique 10 months ago:

Mi humilde opinión es que las columnas no enriquecen la toma. El colorido de las flores aporta vigor y alegría, siempre agradecida.
Saludos

aloha_photo (Jeff Sisemoore) added a critique 10 months ago:

I like this photo. The blurred flowers in the foreground send my eyes immediately to the posts and help establish depth in the picture. Having said that, the posts are only mildly interesting in and of themselves. I think this photo would be improved if there was some additional point of interest located next to the posts...perhaps a young girl reaching down to pick one of the flowers, or an old gardener leaning on a rake. The photo is fine as is, just able to be so much more. By the way, I like the colors in this garden. I bet it's a nice place to visit.

Ana (Ana Cortez) said 10 months ago:

Thank you both for your comments.
Jeff, I agree with you about the photo needing another subject. I originally took this photograph because of the shadows.

boyd added a critique 10 months ago:

I am not so sure that this does need anything else. I agree that the colours and the sense of depth are very well composed here. Perhaps the only thing that I seem to stumble across is the post lined up with the tree trunk, maybe a step or two to the right would have allowed the tree to shine beyond the posts.

JaviNavarro (Javier Navarro) added a critique 9 months ago:

when I see the photo, it seems that columns are the main subject. There are more interesting elements in the image but they are out of focus (flowers) or they are very poorly contrasted (tree), so you look at the columns again at the end. And columns aren't interesting...

Sorry, that's my opinion :)

Afoklala (Jan Willem van Dormolen) added a critique 1 month ago:

I don't think the picture needs more, I'ld rather go for less. Crop off the horizontal beams in the top of the picture, and not only the whole things gets an abstract quality, but also the tree jumps up in the attention. I don't think it'ld make for a perfect picture, but it would definitely be an improvement, IMHO.

You could comment on this photo if you were logged in.